
The Northwest Environmental Training
Center presents:
Modeling Pesticides in the Aquatic Environment
Principles and Methods of Modeling Transport and Fate
Course ID: HYD-403 ( 3.5 days )
April 7-10, 2009, 8:30 A.M. to 5 P.M.
ExecuTrain - Sacramento
1860 Howe Ave, Suite 250
Sacramento, California
Instructors: Tammara Estes, Senior Research Scientist, Stone Environmental, Inc.
& Michael Winchell, GIS Specialist / Hydrologist, Stone Environmental, Inc.
THIS CLASS IS FULL.
Please click on the link below to be added to our waitlist, and keep an eye on our course calendar as it is updated for future HYD-403 classes.
Waitlist | Directions | Accommodations | Course Catalog | Course Brochure (pdf)
Description: This workshop will focus on modeling methodologies as they are typically used to estimate pesticide concentrations in surface water. The course will follow a hands-on approach and will be geared toward environmental scientists with minimal modeling experience. The course is designed to instruct attendees on the use of these models so that the attendees may reproduce and interpret generated pesticide assessments in the future.
Course material will be presented through interactive lectures with accompanying hands-on exercises. The exercises will be based on a single example so the students build a surface water assessment from the ground up. This will simulate a normal modeling risk assessment process which would include parameter selection, simulation, output, and output interpretation. The US EPA has developed a model shell called PE5 that combines the field-scale runoff/leaching model PRZM with the surface water model EXAMS to estimate pesticide concentrations in surface water. Using this shell, students will be guided through a typical surface water exposure assessment along with examination of results. This will be followed by examination of PRZM and EXAMS model use outside of the shell.
|
Course Topics:
Day
1: Tuesday, April 7, 2009, 8:30 A.M. - 5 P.M. |
Day
2: Wednesday, April 8, 2009, 8:30 A.M. - 5 P.M. |
Morning Session: Principles of Modeling
This session will discuss the differences and similarities of empirical versus explanatory modeling. Basic modeling terminology and concepts will be covered, including how mathematical models are based on conceptual models and evolve over time as additional knowledge is obtained and testing of the model occurs.
- What is a model?
- Kinds of models, including deterministic vs. stochastic, and deterministic/explanatory vs. empirical
- Model formats
- Old fashioned FORTRAN card format input files along with their pitfalls (e.g. PRZM and EXAMS without shell)
- Graphical User Interface models and their pitfalls (e.g. PE5)
- Domain of applicability along with its analogy with statistical regression; interpolation vs. extrapolation
- Basic discussion of PRZM and EXAMS models
Afternoon Session: How to Identify Appropriate Environmental Modeling Parameters
This session will review environmental fate processes relevant to surface water modeling. These concepts will be reinforced with an exercise in which the students examine a set of field data to identify the appropriate input parameters (e.g. soil and weather). The identified parameters will be entered into a PRZM exercise, and discussions will include the hazards of over-extrapolating results from developed scenarios to other geographical areas where the environmental conditions are different.
- Weather
- Hydrology
- Stream flow velocity
- Sedimentation
- Rainfall
- Surface water runoff and infiltration
- Runoff amounts and intensity
- Hydrologic Soil Groups (HSG)
- SCS Runoff curve numbers
- Antecedent moisture
- Sediment transport - Universal Soil Loss Equation
- Drift
|
Morning Session: How to Identify Appropriate Pesticide Modeling Parameters
This session will discuss pesticide environmental fate processes and application methods. These concepts will be reinforced with an exercise in which the students examine a set of data to identify the appropriate environmental fate and application method input parameters using PE5.
- Chemical fate
- Adsorption
- Degradation
- First order degradation
- Kinds of degradation (e.g. photodegradation, anaerobic/aerobic degradation, hydrolysis, volatilization)
- Pesticide application methodology relevant to aquatic systems
- Terrestrial applications: incorporation, dormant orchard applications, commercial structural applications
- Water applications: drift issues and aquatic pesticides
Afternoon Session: How to Work with Modeling Results
This session will discuss the concept of uncertainty associated with model input parameters (and thus model output results). This session will also address sensitivity analysis, model calibration, and model validation, as well as a discussion on Mote Carlo techniques and probabilistic model output methods to assess model uncertainty.
- Uncertainty in modeling: Biological variability, sampling variability, input parameter selection effect on model results
- Model Input Parameter Sensitivity
- Calibration to field data
- Model validation
- What is validation?
- Statistics relevant to validation
- Regression and other techniques
- Statistical concepts relevant to stochastic output
- Cumulative sampling distributions
- Parametric vs. empirical
- Examples of stochastic output
- Concept of lumped parameters
|
Day
3: Thursday, April 9, 2009, 8:30 A.M. - 5 P.M. |
Day
4: Friday, April 10, 2009, 8:30 A.M. - 12:00 NOON |
Morning Session: How to Review a Modeling Report
This session will focus on reviewing a modeling report for submission purposes. The class will be guided through what to think about when reviewing a model report.
- Is the employed model appropriate for the current problem?
- Is the provided model input sufficient for reproduction of the modeling study?
- Is the currently accepted version of the employed model used in the modeling study? If a previous version is used, what implications (if any) are likely to result from use of an older version?
- Is the report internally consistent?
- Is the model validated? Is the employed version of the model validated?
- Was the model calibrated to this situation?
- Is the author seeming to hide something?
- Is author biased or ego involved?
- Does the author have reason to shade results? If so, is there any indication they have done so?
- Is modeling within the appropriate domain for the model? (e.g. time / space)
- Are results consistent with other known empirical data and physical properties?
Afternoon Session
- Scale Considerations
This session will expand the modeling to include issues about scale, both spatial and temporal. The PRZM/EXAMS modeling exercise will be expanded to include simulating 30 weather years to assess the effect of changes in results over time. Discussion of daily time step versus smaller increments will be conducted. Other surface water models will be discussed/demonstrated in this session including GLEAMS, RZWQM, SWAT, RICEWQ, and SWMM.
- Spatial scale (e.g. edge of field vs. watershed)
- Temporal scale
- Episodic vs. daily mean
- Dictated in part by model's minimum time step
|
Morning Session: Model Comparisons and Wrap Up
This session will include comparison of the models discussed from the perspective of:
- Input requirements
- Internal algorithms
- Computational requirements
- Published validation reports
- Individual model strengths and weaknesses
- Model assumptions
- Intended usage
- Using multiple models in a similar manner to help address model uncertainty
The final exercises will include actively running some of the models and then comparing the results. The students will be encouraged to examine whether the differences are due too differences in the internal algorithms of the model, differences in model assumptions, availability of necessary model information, or differences in sensitivity of input parameters between the models. |
After completing this course, participants will be able to:
- Use models to reproduce and interpret generated pesticide assessments
- Understand what modeling is all about
- Inculcate healthy skepticism towards modeling
- Becoming familiar with modeling vocabulary
- Become familiar with surface water modeling vocabulary, including review of environmental fate concepts relevant to surface water
- Become familiar with main surface water models currently available
- Evaluate the uncertainties associated with model input parameter selection and how this might impact the resulting risk assessment
- Understand the difference between stochastic and deterministic models
- Understand the difference between model validation and calibration
- Review a modeling report and ask appropriate questions about the validity of the modeling and underlying parameter selection assumptions
- Understand the general process of modeling along with its shortcomings
About the Instructors:
Tammara Estes, Senior Research Scientist
Working out of Stone's Chicago office, Ms. Tammara Estes is responsible for evaluating and modeling the environmental fate and ecological effects of crop protection chemicals in the United States. She is an agrochemical industry leader in environmental simulation modeling, statistical analysis, and environmental risk assessment of crop protection chemicals in surface water, groundwater, and soils. A biomathematician by training, Ms. Estes has over 20 years of experience working with exposure issues and risk assessment concerning crop protection chemicals. She has extensive knowledge of the major regulatory models and methods that are in use today in the US, Canada and Europe. She has successfully applied this knowledge to numerous registration efforts. Ms. Estes is also a very experienced instructor. For the past five years, she has been an adjunct professor of mathematics at Oakton Community College. Her specialty is teaching mathematics for teacher certification where she is noted for her ability to communicate complex mathematical concepts in understandable terms.
Michael Winchell, Senior GIS Specialist / Hydrologist
Michael Winchell is a Senior GIS Specialist / Hydrologist in the Applied Information Management group of Stone Environmental in Montpelier, Vermont. Mr. Winchell is an expert in the use of GIS techniques in the assessment of watershed vulnerability to nutrient and pesticide loadings, GIS application development, and watershed scale modeling or surface water. he is the principal developer of the ArcGIS interface for the SWAT model and has taught several SWAT modeling courses, including a 3-day course he developed which focused on the application of SWAT specifically for pesticide modeling. Mr. Winchell has developed and taught several GIS courses for clients that include the Nature Conservancy and the Vermont Department of Health. His experience in teaching hydrology and water resources extends back to teaching undergraduate hydrology courses at the University of Arizona as a graduate teaching assistant. Prior to joining Stone Environmental, Mr. Winchell worked with the National Weather Service Northeast River Forecast Center where he developed rainfall-runoff, flow routing, and reservoir operation models for use in real-time flood forecasting applications. As part of this modeling effort, Mr. Winchell implemented cutting-edge techniques for efficient and effective rainfall-runoff model calibration. Mr. Winchell earned his Masters degree in Hydrology and Water Resources from the University of Arizona where he studied under Dr. Soroosh Sorooshian. Mr. Winchell earned his undergraduate degree in Environmental Systems Technology from the Department of Agricultural Engineering at Cornell University.
Intended Audience: This course is geared toward environmental scientists with minimal modeling experience. The course will be designed to instruct the attendees on the use of these models so that the attendees may reproduce and interpret generated pesticide assessments in the future.
Prerequisites: Some experience working with models will be helpful, but not required.
Education Level: Introductory/Review
Course Materials: Participants will receive course proceedings and accompanying CDs which will contain copies of the handouts, the main surface water models, model shells, exercises, and example output files.
Continuing Education Units: 2.3
What to Bring: Pen
or pencil, coffee mug, and a water bottle (to reduce waste). Please wear comfortable clothes
appropriate for the prevailing weather. Lunch will be provided each day, as well as drinks and snacks.
Registration: $1,695 ($1,495 reduced rates*)
You may register via the link below or by calling the Northwest Environmental Training Center at 206-762-1976.
Registration includes: Lunch each day, course materials and accommpanying CDs containing copies of the handouts, the main surface water models, model shells, exercises, and example output files.
(*reduced tuition
is available for Native American tribes; government employees; nonprofits; students;
and NAEP, NEBC, NWAEP members).
Cancellation Policy: Registration fees are fully refundable up to 30 days prior to the event (through March 6, 2009) and 50 percent refundable (or 100% credit) thereafter up to 5 business days prior to the event (through March 31, 2009). No refunds are issued for cancellations occurring less than 5 business days before the start day. Course registration fees and cancellation policy are subject to change without notice.
Disability Accommodations: To request disability accommodations, please contact us at info@nwetc.org or (206) 762-1976 at least 30 days prior to the event. |
Northwest Environmental Training
Center
A 501(c)(3) non-profit program of EOS Alliance
650 S. Orcas Street, Suite 220, Seattle, Washington 98108
Phone: (206)762-1976, Fax: (206)762-1979
www.nwetc.org
|